US President Barack Obama's comments on religious intolerance in India have provoked sharp reactions in the country. There is no formal response from the Narendra Modi government yet, but some opposition parties say the statement reaffirms their concerns.
On Thursday, in a 25-minute address to the National Prayer Breakfast, President Obama referred to India while talking about religious freedom. "Michelle and I returned from India -- an incredible, beautiful country, full of magnificent diversity -- but a place where, in past years, religious faiths of all types have, on occasion, been targeted by other peoples of faith, simply due to their heritage and their beliefs -- acts of intolerance that would have shocked Gandhiji, the person who helped to liberate that nation," he said.
"I think President Obama's comments are not in reference to any community. He was referring to general intolerance. A similar order remains in the US as well, so religious tolerance is a challenge for the biggest and largest democracy," said GVL Narasimha Rao, a spokesperson of the ruling BJP.
The BJP's political rivals took digs at Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
"Did the Prime Ministerial Tea reinforce Barrack's understanding of the revival ism & intolerance intrinsic in the BJP govt Another stinker? (sic)," Congress leader Manish Tewari said in an acerbic tweet.
"I think Mr Modi will answer this, they are very good friends," quipped Arvind Kejriwal, the chief of the Aam Aadmi Party.
Bihar politician Lalu Yadav tweeted, "My position on religious liberty endorsed by @BarackObama,yesterday."
The Congress ally also said, "Mr. PM for the sake of united India,if u get time out of ur street electioneering thn plz defend &promote d right to freedom of religion."
President Obama's words are being seen by some as a significant follow-up to his appeal for religious freedom on the last day of his India visit.
"India will succeed so long as it is not splintered on religious lines," he said at a townhall-style meeting in Delhi, adding, "Nowhere is it more important to uphold religious freedom than in India."
Many interpreted it as a scathing critique at a time the Modi government has been accused of not reining in individuals and groups seen to promote a pro-Hindu agenda.
But this week, the White House said the speech had been misconstrued by some commentators as a kind of a parting shot.
"I think that's been somewhat misconstrued, if you look at the context of the entire speech, it's really about inclusivity. It's about the power of diversity," Phil Reiner, White House's senior director for South Asian Affairs said.
................................ Advertisement ................................
Opinion: China Has Helped India's Cause With TrumpMihir Sharma, Bloomberg
Thursday June 29, 2017Very little was expected in India from Prime Minister Narendra Modi's visit to the U.S., and for good reason: Modi had gone out of his way to cultivate a personal relationship with Barack Obama, including famously pouring out a cup of tea for him and the cameras when Obama visited India.
Opinion: Modi's US Speech Was Letter Perfect, Ticked Off Every BoxAshok Malik
Friday June 10, 2016Without taking recourse to the old wailing sheet and cribbing to everyone about Islamabad, Modi has devised a mechanism to shape the debate to India's advantage.
Opinion: Modi Ignored Advice To Make Obama Squirm. It Has Paid Off.Jyoti Malhotra
Saturday June 04, 2016The visit to the US in the coming week, in fact, brings Obama's relationship with both Modi and India full circle.
Blogs: कादम्बिनी के कीबोर्ड से : क्या परमाणु करार पर पीछे हटे हम?
Sunday February 08, 2015असल में परमाणु रिएक्टरों में हादसे की सूरत में जो हर्जाना होगा, वह रिएक्टर चलाने वाले को यानि ऑपरेटर को देना होगा। कानून में यह प्रावधान है कि अगर ऑपरेटर चाहे तो वह सामान और ईंधन आपूर्ति करने वाले पर हर्जाने के लिए दावा कर सकता है। लेकिन यहां पर समझने वाली बात यह है कि ऑपरेटर कौन होगा।
Opinion: Mani-Talk: Modi is Turning Us into America's New PakistanMani Shankar Aiyar
Thursday February 12, 2015In "Cold War II", battlefield could be India, writes Mani Shankar Aiyar.
Opinion: Obama Had Pointed Message for Modi 2.0Shashi Tharoor
Wednesday January 28, 2015Clear warning that PM will fail if he reverts to Modi 1.0, writes Shashi Tharoor.
Opinion: What Pakistan Makes of Obama-Modi ChemistryMehr Tarar
Tuesday January 27, 2015Acceptance of Modi's goal-oriented leadership, writes Mehr Tarar.