Fighting Our Killer Air - A Citizens' Charter
  • Home/
  • Opinion | New Delhi's Air Quality Can Choke Its Geopolitical Influence

Opinion | New Delhi's Air Quality Can Choke Its Geopolitical Influence

Nishtha Gautam

Nishtha Gautam

Opinion | New Delhi's Air Quality Can Choke Its Geopolitical Influence
Latest and Breaking News on NDTV

In an ongoing hearing, the Supreme Court of India has decried the Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM) for not serving its purpose. The Commission was set up in 2021 through an ordinance after the Air Quality Management in National Capital Region and Adjoining Areas Act 2021 was introduced in the Lok Sabha on July 30, 2021. What the apex court has observed is that three years, millions of dollars, and several opportunities have gone down the drain while India's capital, yet again, prepares to choke.

People of New Delhi, policymakers and plebeians alike, seem to have eased into the city's toxicity: polluters continue to pollute without any fear of penalty or punishment, and the wealthy find ways to avoid being in the city during the choke months - November to February. The world, however, is watching the poison in Delhi's air with a bated breath.

The 'Hardship Allowance'

Earlier this year, New Delhi was adjudged to be the most polluted capital city in the world, according to the sixth Annual World Air Quality Report. The city's air has PM2.5 concentrations that are more than ten times the WHO annual guideline. This factoid on paper reads straight out of a dystopian work. The US Department of State categorises New Delhi as a city that merits a "Post (Hardship) Differential" allowance. The hardship allowance for being posted to India's capital is pegged at 25% of basic compensation - the same as the bombed-out Beirut or the regional posts in Antarctica or the Arctic Circle. In 1997, this allowance used to be 10%.  

What it means on an everyday basis is even more disturbing. Despite a substantially heftier pay packet, diplomats are hesitant. Delhi is scary. It is no coincidence that most embassies and high commissions begin to show signs of thinning personnel strength post-autumn every year. The 'holiday' season starts early in New Delhi. There are two ways of reacting to this phenomenon: brushing it off as typical Global North snobbery or assessing the implications of being treated at par with a war zone.

Passing The Buck, Every Year

New Delhi's inability to control pollution is seen as a failure of the country's democratic governance. It is, after all, commonsensical to ask how robust the mechanisms of the world's largest democracy are when they cannot ensure even clean air in the national capital region. What the world witnesses is a perpetual passing-the-buck game every year while hazardous conditions continue to jeopardise people's health and livelihoods.

India's biggest calling card in the global arena is its unwavering commitment to democracy. This is what sets New Delhi apart from other capitals like Beijing or Abu Dhabi in terms of promise. The failure to check the pollution hazard becomes a stick with which to beat India's democracy. Can we afford this undermining?

Let's take the geopolitics aspect of environmental deterioration a little further. In 2010, the Middle East region saw a sharp decline in air pollution levels, becoming an outlier. Reduced economic activity due to sanctions and conflicts was cited as the primary driver for this phenomenon. For example, the UN-backed sanctions on Iran led to lower emissions from oil tankers in the Persian Gulf. Strife in Syria precluded any industrial growth, leading to a significant improvement in the air quality. How long before the rich and the powerful get certain ideas on tackling environmental deterioration? 

India Can't Just Wish Away The Problem

India has been promoting itself as a powerful player in the global security gambit. It seems to be getting almost too sure of its importance. However, when it comes to environmental policy, European and North American countries might want to weather the geopolitical risks. A 2023 study published by the Journal of Environmental Management indicates that while "geopolitical risks significantly influence environmental policy" in many EU member states, "environmental policy causes geopolitical risks only in Latvia". The message is clear. Perceived geopolitical risks are unlikely to undermine environmental policies. Is India certain of cushioning itself against this altered approach that renders it not so important anymore?

Already, India is being decried as one of the world's most significant polluters. Our prickliness and denunciation of such proclamations cannot mitigate their reputational damage.  

There are further complications to New Delhi's air issue. While we are somewhat fortunate to have even more polluted neighbours - Bangladesh and Pakistan - a diplomatic event with the potential to become territorial and military cannot be ruled out. Recently, the South Korean government monitored and quantified the influence of border-crossing particulate matter from China. This is literally taking the fight to atmospheric levels. Pakistan, along similar lines, blames the farm fires of Punjab (and Haryana) directly impacting Lahore's air quality.

New Delhi can continue to sit and watch the many fires in its backyard without changing the status quo. However, it should be prepared for the consequences such a signalling may entail. 

(Nishtha Gautam is a Delhi-based author and academic.)

Disclaimer: These are the personal opinions of the author

Share this story on

Latest Stories

................................ Advertisement ................................

Latest Videos

Opinion

  • Opinion | Why Indians Have Just Given Up On Air Pollution Crisis

    Opinion | Why Indians Have Just Given Up On Air Pollution CrisisTanushree Ganguly

    Friday December 20, 2024

    While some may argue that people in Delhi are now more aware of air pollution than they were a decade back, my rebuttal would be that awareness does not mean that people are concerned.

  • Opinion | You Must Outrage Over Filthy Air More Than Once A Year

    Opinion | You Must Outrage Over Filthy Air More Than Once A YearJyoti Pande Lavakare

    Tuesday December 10, 2024

    Delhi welcomed us with monsoon rains and mangos. We were home. Fast forward a couple of years, in the winter of 2012, I found myself in denial about something other parents, mostly expats, were calling toxic air.

  • Opinion | Delhi's Air Pollution Situation Is Like A Bad Marriage

    Opinion | Delhi's Air Pollution Situation Is Like A Bad MarriageNishtha Gautam

    Friday November 22, 2024

    On a good day, such as today, the AQI reading in Delhi is 407. We are jubilant at the sickly sunshine trickling through the slightly dissipated smog. At least its not 1600.

  • दिवाली... पराली... सियासी जुगाली!

    दिवाली... पराली... सियासी जुगाली!Ashwini kumar

    Monday November 18, 2024

    दिल्ली-एनसीआर में प्रदूषण का समाधान तो आज तक मिला नहीं. हर साल चिंतित होकर हम-आप सांसों की तकलीफ के साथ-साथ दिल और ब्लड प्रेशर के मरीज भी क्यों बनें?

  • घर में कैद बुजुर्ग और हांफते लोग, दिल्ली की सांसों में घुला ये कैसा रोग?

    घर में कैद बुजुर्ग और हांफते लोग, दिल्ली की सांसों में घुला ये कैसा रोग?Nidhi Kulpati

    Friday November 08, 2024

    हमारी हवा जहरीली हो रही है. गुरुवार की शाम को जब मैं इस मुद्दे पर लिखने बैठी तो AQI लगातार 400 पार  जाकर दम घोंट रहा था. बहुत लोगों को यह मामला बोरिंग लगे, लेकिन जब आप अपने साथ काम करने वालों को खांसते-हांफते देखते-सुनते हैं, तो चिंता होने लगती है. सुबह उठते ही दरवाजे खिड़कियां खोलने के लिए डॉक्टर मना कर रहे हैं. बड़े बुजुर्गों के लिए तो मॉर्निंग वॉक बाहर की दुनिया से सीधे संपर्क का ज़रिया है, लेकिन डॉक्टर इसकी भी मनाही कर रहे हैं.